Search billions of records on Ancestry.com

CORPSE IN THE CEDAR CHEST

by Sam Gordon

Finally the power shovel brought up a large box and in it  was found  the body of  Virginia Cantrell  with bullet holes in the chest and head.
 
Nobody had ever said that State "Trooper Jack Music ever  had a  easy  job.   His tour  of  duties  includes a section of Eastern Kentucky where gritty mountaineers
live in a provincial world all their own . Natives are  tight-  lipped and rumors are rare in Johnson County.   That's why persistent talk about one woman's strange disappearance aroused the curiosity of Music. He called the County  Attorney   D.C. VanHoose  about it while the latter was in Paintsville in connection  with  the January 1959  term  of   Johnson  County  Circuit Courts.  The woman's  name is  Mrs. Virginia  Cantrell", Music explained.  "She hasn't been seen since last October. Her husband says she ran out on him: The County Attorney had  heard the same rumors.   Some of  the  hill people were saying "Virgie" Cantrell had been  murdered. When did this talk start?  "VanHoose asked. Jack Music told him  that  was difficult  to say  " I first heard the rumors back in December, and people must have been talking a long time before I got wind of it. They don't  tell their troubles to  outsiders very  readily.    The  trooper told VanHoose as much  as he knew about Virgie Cantrell.  "She  is 44 years  old," he said.  "Dark haired, about 5 feet  2 inches  tall  and of  slight attractive build.  She is from  a  large, long established Johnson County family and  was one of  the  prettiest and most popular girls in Paintsville  before she  married  Henry Cantrell.   They live on a farm in  Fuget.    That's 13 miles northwest of Paintsville in the Red Bush section. 
 

 Jack  Music  went on  to  say  the Cantrell' s had  one daughter, Loretta.  "I've talked to several people about the Cantrell's.  Nobody has ever heard  of  marital trouble there. People say that whatever Henry did was all right with Virgie, that she never believed any wrong on him.

          
    The County Attorney  was puzzled.  He knew that loyalty was one of the stronger characteristics of these mountain people.  "If Virgie Cantrell loved her husband so much," he asked, " why would she run out on him.?'
 Trooper Music and everybody else in Johnson County had been wondering the same thing. "That's why people are  talking."   he  told  VanHoose.  " The thing doesn't add up".

 

Both the County Attorney and Jack  Music knew quite a bit about Henry Cantrell.  He is 51 years old, a rugged backwoodsman typical of  the section in which he lived.  Like his  wife,   Henry  is  from  an  old Johnson County  family.    The   hills  and  hollows  of    Eastern Kentucky are full of Cantrell's.

 

Henry had been a constable a while back. He had also worked  on  county  roads  as a bulldozer operator for several  years ,  but   he  was   not  employed   in   that capacity at the time VanHoose and Music were talking about his wife's strange disappearance.

 

"He used  to  run the Knotty Pine Inn at Paintsville with his daughter, Loretta the Trooper reminded VanHoose "There was trouble about  the sale of  whiskey and  the place was closed."    Johnson County is in local option territory.

VanHoose remembered the Knotty Pine Inn and much more.    Rumor had  it  that  Henry  Cantrell   obtained whiskey in Mount Sterling, KY. and brought  it back in his 1957 black  Mercury  via  a little traveled road that passed the home of Mrs. Evalena Stamper about a mile from the Cantrell place Mrs. Stamper was bludgeoned and strangled to death on Thursday morning, November 20,  1958.  Sheriff  James Phipps  believed  the motive for  the crime  was  robbery.   The only clue  to the unsolved case  was that a black  late model car had been seen parked in front of Mrs. Stamper's house with the motor running for some time the morning of the murder.

 

   There also came to VanHoose's mind the robbery of the  Big  Sandy  Hardware  Company in Paintsville the first  week  in  August ,  1958.    Part  of  the  loot,  15 shotguns,  four rifles,  12 electric razors, pocket knives and rifle and shotgun shells, was  recovered among tall weeds in a deserted  hollow  in  Mud Lick Creek.  But most of the stolen property was never found.  Some of Henry Cantrell 's relatives and  friends  had  been convicted of that crime.

 

County Attorney  VanHoose  and  Jack  Music   went over all  this  data  and  speculation.   Certainly  Henry Cantrell had not even been arrested in connection with either  the  murder of  Mrs. Stamper  or  the Hardware robbery .  Still  the  strange  disappearance of  his wife and the talk about  her murder was worth investigating.

 

VanHoose  said,"I"ll  pass  what  little  information we have   concerning  Virgie  Cantrell  along to Common- wealth  Attorney  W. H. Hazelrigg.  He  can  study the facts and make the next move."

 

Hazelrigg listened  to  what  VanHoose had to say and concluded  that where there was so much smoke there could   be  fire.  He  requested  Detective  Chester  D. Potter, with  headquarters in Pikeville, to make a complete investigation.

 

Forward to Corpse In The Cedar Chest page 2

 Return to Johnson County Newspaper Clippings