The Battle of Blue Licks Centennial
Monument Dedication, 1882
The Flemingsburg Times newspaper issued a supplementary issue on
August 26, 1882, which presented coverage of the centennial anniversary of the
battle of Blue Licks. The celebration was held on the battlefield on August 19,
1882. Those in attendance at the ceremony included, Governor L. P. Blackburn and
his staff, "the Historical Society Orators and Poet, descendants of the
heroes of the battle, distinguished invited guests, Carlisle Commandery of
Knight Templars, company of pioneers, five companies of State Guards, viz.,
McCreary guards, Lexington Guards, Blackburn Guards, Nuckols Buards, Emmett
Guards, citizens in carriages, citizens on horseback and citizens on
afoot." Several rather lengthy speeches were reported in the newspaper
article.
The address of Mrs. Thomas L. Jones described portions of the battle as follows.
"Who of us that in days gone by were accustomed to visit the Blue Lick
Springs does not remember the interest with which we listened to the thrilling
story of the battle between the Indians and pioneers and how, when we drove to
the battleground, we would stop to behold the spot, and to hear it told that
there were the two ravines where the savages lay in ambush and whence they came
up and surprised the whites.
Let us congratulate ourselves that we are assembled today, under circumstances
so solemn and imposing to mark the spot on the sacred soil and to assist in
laying the cornerstone of a monument to the brave men who here sacrificed their
lives a hundred years ago.
It is appropriate that the Historical Society should participate in the
impressive ceremonies of this centennial anniversary, and the ladies' branch,
while uniting in doing honor to the heroes of this battle, embraces the
opportunity to celebrate the bravery of the women of that pioneer period.
History tells us that four days before the battle of the blue Licks, six hundred
Indians, guided by the notorious Simon Girty, having appeared before Bryan's
Station, demanded the surrender of the fort, and then was performed that ever
memorable act of courage upon the part of the women.
The fort was destitute of water, the spring at some distance. The men dared not
expose themselves to the fire of the savages, who were in ambush on either side,
and in this dire necessity, they summoned the women, who with fearless
composure, marched in a body to the spring, filled their buckets and retraced
their steps in safety, bearing the life giving element in the suffering
garrison. The siege was raised and the Indians disappeared. The fort having been
reinforced, the pioneers were elated with hope, and rashly impetuous, without
waiting for General Logan's superior force to join them, they pursued the savage
foe and precipitated the attack, which resulted in the cruel slaughter of so
many brave men.
The ridge, the ravines and the river were crimson with the blood of the flower
of Kentucky's chivalry. The survivors fled in dismay to Bryan's Station, where
the same noble women were ready to comfort and to cheer. Mourning was spread
over the land as the lamentations resounded from settlement to settlement
throughout the district. The incidents of that battle fill the bloodiest page in
the annals of Kentucky pioneer warfare.
How forcibly do the recurrences of history serve to bring before us events of
the past! In the now frequent deadly encounters with the Indians in the distant
Territories are re-enacted the perilous adventure of our pioneer settlers. And
when we recall the dreadful Indian massacre, only a few years ago of General
Custer's force on the Little Big Horn, but on the far Western frontier, where
fell our own gallant young Crittenden, we are somewhat taught what the grief
must have been when messengers bore through the wilderness to the mother State,
Virginia, tidings of bloody Blue Licks, where many an adventurous son had
perished.
The names of the heroes of the Blue Licks have been consecrated within the life
of the State of Kentucky. Their descendants and kindred have been from time to
time, distinguished in the service of their country, and now occupy the high
positions of Secretary of War and a Justice of the United States Supreme Court.
Mrs. Abraham Lincoln, whose dirge has so recently been sung, was a relative of
Colonel John Todd, who here fell first in command.
Dear to the hearts of Kentucky are the names of al her heroes, dearer still will
they become as time rolls on and other...to brighter her historical horizon and
kindle the enthusiasm of her people. Amidst the enjoyment of our great
prosperity and high advance it is difficult to realize the hardships and
privations of a hundred years ago, nor can we ever learn all the trials, which
our pioneer mothers so nobly endured in the settlement of this beautiful land.
But we know that their energy, fortitude and courage have been inherited by
their daughters. From the capture of Betsy and Fanny Calloway and Jemima Boone
by the Indians in 1776, down to the latest days of danger, the women of Kentucky
have exhibited an intrepidity worthy of admiration. In every war they have
watched and waited and hoped. The battlefields, the hospitals and the prisons
have witnessed deeds of female heroism, which may yet adorn the pages of
history.
The women of our State would share with men in honor and laudation to her brave
defenders. And we of the Historical Society, with reverence for the heroes slain
at the Blue Licks, assist in laying the cornerstone of this Battle Monument, and
when it shall rise, and the sculptor shall thereon inscribe the names and
delineate the tragic scenes of August 19, 1782, let them mingle with the epitaph
and be carved in bas relief, a grateful tribute to the noble women of Bryan's
Station."
A portion of the address of Colonel John Mason Brown reviewed the history of the
troubles with the Indians that led eventually to the Battle of Blue Licks. In a
couple of areas, parts of a sentence was obscured by the fold of the newspaper.
This is noted by (...) I also skipped some parts that just went on and on,
rhetorically.
"From the time when John Finley, in 1767, crossing the Cumberland from
North Carolina, penetrated to the valley of Elkhorn and the Kentucky River, and
returning, told of the hunters' paradise he had found beyond the mountains, the
romantic story takes its beginning. Who he was and who were two or three that
bore him company in his adventure, we shall never know. No history of them has
been written, nor has tradition preserved more than the mere name of Finley. But
in no assembly of our people should his name be mentioned, save with honor, for
he made the double discovery of the country of Kentucky and of Daniel Boone, its
pioneer.
The story which Finley told of his expedition into the new country was listened
to with eager ears by the adventurous men, who like himself, had already pushed
their habitations far into the solitudes of Western North Carolina. The spring
of 1769 saw him returning to his new found hunting grounds and with him the five
companions whom every historian of our State must record as the advance guard of
Kentucky. They were with the single exception of Boone, obscure men, whose past
experience was of the rudest life, and to whom no dream of ambition or thought
of fame was known. They filled their appointed place in the great drama that was
preparing and passed into oblivion with the shifting of its first scene.
John Stuart, Joseph Holden, James Mooney and William Cool, with Finley and Boone
were the first that ever Burst into the unknown West. (This is not the present
day version of the first white men in Kentucky). It is much to be regretted that
Boone in the brief narrative, which he dictated to Filson, did not identify more
closely the spot, as he so accurately fixed the time, where the little band
first was the glorious panorama of Central Kentucky.
'On the 7th June (so runs Boone's narrative), after traveling through a
mountainous wilderness, in a western direction, we found ourselves on Red River,
where John Finley had formerly been trading with the Indians, and from the top
of an eminence saw with pleasure the beautiful level of Kentucke.'
A number of considerations, as well topographical as historical, seem to warrant
the opinion that the spot whence Boone and his companions had this memorable
first view of their promised land, must have been in the near vicinity of the
Indian Old Fields, eastward of the town of Winchester and on the waters of
Lulbegrad Creek.
Finley had trade in some small fashion with the Indians, as we learn from Boone
and doubtless conducted his little party to the localities, which he had before
best known. The Shawnees alone, of all the Indian tribes, had attempted a
permanent settlement in Kentucky, and had as late as 1750, perhaps later,
occupied a town on the Lulbegrud. The subsequent return of Boone to that
vicinity and the ready explanation, which the topography of the country gives of
his ultimate explorations along the watercourses and settlement at Boonesborough,
seems to confirm the conjecture. But the office of Finley and Holden and Mooney
and Cool and Stuart was as has been remarked, only to introduce to his new
empire the prince of pioneers.
On the 22nd of December, Boone and Stuart were captured by Indians and escaped a
few days later, only to find, on returning to their former haunts, that their
comrades were gone and the camp destroyed.
The lonely survivors were cheered, however by the appearance of Squire Boone,
who had with a single companion followed his brother into the wilderness, and by
mere chance, discovered his camp. But Stuart was soon after killed by the
Indians, and the stranger abandoned them, so that the brothers Boone spent the
winter of 1769-1770 together, the only whites within Kentucky, an isolation only
to be made absolute by the return of Squire Boone to North Carolina in May 1770.
The pioneer was left alone without bread, salt or sugar or even a horse or dog.
It was from such a small beginning that our Commonwealth has arisen. The
fortitude, the intelligent courage, the enthusiasm of one man, was the nucleus
about which rapidly gathered an adventurous emigration from the older States...
The spring of the year 1782 opened upon what indeed, seemed an era of prosperity
and security for the West. The surrender of Cornwallis at Yorktown in the
preceding autumn had ended the War of Independence. Peace with England brought
with it a recognized American title to the great Northwest as far as the lakes
and beyond Detroit. The splendid dream of Clark, which none but Jefferson seemed
fully to comprehend, was fulfilled in the cession of an empire. Strong men had
come in numbers to seek fortune and adventure in the brakes and forests of
Kentucky. Brave women encountered the hardships of the frontier, and followed
husbands and fathers into the wilderness. Families had been established and
children had been born to the pioneer. Already was cradled the generation of
Kentucky riflemen destined to crush in after years, the great confederation of
Tecumseh, and to assure the northern boundary of the Union.
The log cabin, which James Harrod built in 1774, first of log cabins in the
wilderness of Kentucky, no longer stood solitary in the West. Around it others
had risen and the hamlet of Harrodsburg been formed. At that place formal
territorial councils had been held and resolutions of supreme public importance
been taken. Louisville had begun to rise and a village to cluster at the Falls
of the Ohio. Lexington had been named and settled, protected in its infant
growth by the stations, which Todd, on the one side, and Bryant in another
quarter, had for several years maintained. Stout Ben Logan held St. Asaph
Station, near the present town of Stanford, and towards the North and East, on
the southern tributaries of the Licking, lay Martin's and Ruddge's Stations,
advanced posts, watching the incursion of the Mingos, the Shawnees, the
Delawares, and the Wyandots, who dwelt beyond the Ohio. A growing sense of
security prevailed.
Commerce too then plumed her wing for a more daring flight than two centuries
had known. Filled with the inspiration of those brave days, Jacob Yoder in May
1782, built at Fort Redston, on the Monongahela, a large flatboat and loading it
with produce, and manning it with a picked crew, he first of all carried
commerce down the broad highway of the Ohio and Mississippi to the Spanish forts
at new Orleans. The return of the adventurers was by way of Havana and
Philadelphia and thence, through Fort Pitt, to the Falls of the Ohio, and thus
was the trade of the South and West opened, by a veritable circumnavigation.
But if the pioneers, worn with the toils of unceasing warfare, and harassed by
the continued incursion of their Indian foe, hailed with grateful hope this
early dawn of the coming day of civilization and peace, a far different feeling
agitated the breasts of their old enemies.
The peace with England ended the subsidies and material support that had given
organized vigor to the Indian war. There were no longer at Detroit, or elsewhere
along the border, men who, disgracing the uniform of a gallant army, and removed
from the control of civilized opinion, incited the barbarities of savage war,
and openly paid in British goods for the scalps of Americans.
Thirty years were to go by before Proctor should abandon his prisoners of war to
a savage massacre, and Elliott permit the murder of the gallant Hart, whose
hospitality he had received while himself a prisoner of war in Kentucky. The
withdrawal of English aid brought serious reflection and well founded alarm to
the abler men of the principle Indian tribes. The fear seemed to them a just one
that the pioneers, who had in smaller numbers and against unexampled
discouragements, withstood the Indians, armed and equipped by British aid, would
now find it but a light task to wrest from their Indian foes all that they might
want of the lands of the Northwest. It was the sad presage of Captain Pipe (Hopocan)
the was chief of the Delawares, that when the whites ceased their wars, the
Indians would be abandoned to an inevitable destruction. This apprehension was
shared by all the most sagacious and influential of his race, and prepared them
for concerted desperate action.
But most potent, perhaps, of all the immediate cause that led to the attack on
the Kentucky settlements in 1782, and to the battle of the Blue Licks, was the
malignant activity of the renegade Simon Girty.
The atrocities attributed to Girty or immediately associated with his name,
exceed the horrors of even savage barbarity. To his bloody imagination the
tomahawk and scalping knife were but the toys of war, and the slaughter of
captives, without distinction of age or sex, the merest matter of course. His
delight was in the prolonged torture of his victims and he seemed to enjoy a
double pleasure in the exquisite torment of the sufferer, and the frenzied
cruelty of the Indians, whom he knew only too well how to excite.
His rude and bold nature had received a sinister education and he seemed marked
from his infancy to be the scourge of the frontier.
Simon Girty was one of four sons of an Irish emigrant, (who) settled in
Pennsylvania, a vicious and drunken wretch, who was killed by his wife's
paramour. The four boys were captured in early childhood by a war party and
three of them permanently adopted an Indian life. George became a Delaware and
continued with them until his death. He is said, of one well informed, to have
lost every trait and habit that marks the white man and to have become an
absolute savage. His fidelity to his adopted people never wavered, indeed, he
knew no other kindred, and he surpassed the native Indian in that skill and
cunning which is peculiarly his own. He is said to have been very brave and to
have fought the whites with skill and distinction at the Kanawha, at Sandusky,
and at the Blue Licks. Tradition has rated him as a mere Indian, and he has
escaped the execration that attaches to his brother's name.
James Girty was adopted by the Shawnees. He passed, in his earlier life,
repeatedly between the camp and war path of the Indian and the frontier
rendezvous of most abandoned whites. He imbibed all the worst vices of both
races and exaggerated them in the fury of an unbridled lust for carnage. His
delight was to devise new and lingering tortures for captives and to superintend
their application.
Even after disease had destroyed his power of walking, he would cause captive
women and children to be force within his reach that he might hew them with his
tomahawk. His life stands unrelieved by a single good deed or a single savage
virtue. Once he pretended to warn some whites against an impending attack, but
it seems probable that some cunning design was hidden behind it. It is possible
as some have insisted, that much of the infamy that has been accorded Simon
Girty, belongs properly to James. It may be that if it were possible to test the
traditions, which have come down to us, an impartial judgment might absolve the
more famous renegade from many a crime that has been laid to his charge. For
Simon Girty showed intellectual qualities and at times was kindly beyond his
brothers or the other renegade whites. He remembered Kenton as an ancient friend
and saved his life. In other instances, he showed an almost pity. But
(unreadable...in his earlier life as a warrior and before the ear 1778.
Simon Girty became, in his childhood, a Seneca Indian. They were his people and
his friends. Though he wandered back at intervals to the verge of the white
settlements, and was even for a brief time, Kenton's comrade as a spy for Lord
Dunsmore's expedition, he returned again to his Indian life. His hatred of the
whites seemed to be intensified when the Indian tribes took up the hatchet as
allies of England and after 1778, he carried on an unrelenting war For such a
man, stained with so many cruelties, abhorred and dreaded throughout the
frontier, to return to his race, or hope to live within the pale of
civilization, was impossible.
The peace with Great Britain left Girty no choice but that of the Indian life,
so congenial to him, no occupation, but that of war to the death. Other whites
too, had like Girty, become identified with the Indians, and had shared in their
barbarities. Elliott and McKee, who had traded with the Shawnees, cast their
fortunes with Girty and like him, devoted every energy to stirring up the
Indians to war.
There were, therefore, abundant reasons why the year 1782 should have been
signalized by a mighty effort against the Kentucky settlements. As has been
seen, the leading Indians looked with dismay to their future, the renegade
whites were desperate. But as often happens when affairs are ripe for great
events, an occasion for revenge, and an argument for a great expedition, was
furnished to the hands of Girty and his allies.
During the preceding year, an expedition of retaliation against the Wyandots had
marched from the Pennsylvania frontier. It was followed in the early spring of
1782 by one under command of Williamson, who chose to think that the Christian
Indians upon the Sandusky, where the Moravian Mission had been established, were
participants in the Wyandots' forays. With a barbarity that might have shamed
Girty, he caused forty men, twenty women and thirty-four children, whom he had
captured to be murdered in cold blood. The awful deed was perpetrated with a
formal deliberation that lent a more revolting horror to the tragedy. Williamson
and his ninety men took a solemn vote and but sixteen favored mercy. The
prisoners had been captured as they gleaned the poor remnants of their ravaged
fields, planted under their missionaries' care, and cultivated as part of their
education into a civilized life. And there they were murdered, all of them,
defenseless and innocent fellow Christians.
The awful crime of Williamson and his party, far from exciting horror, roused
only a frenzy of impatience to complete the work of extermination. Another
expedition was at once organized against the towns of the Moravian Delawares and
Wyandots upon the Sandusky. It rendezvoused not far from Fort Pitt o the 20th
May, and was commanded by Col. William Crawford, the former trusted agent of
Washington. Nearly five hundred men took part in it, all well armed and mounted,
and the purpose of the march was ostentatiously declared; No Indian was to be
spared, friend or foe, every red man was to die.
Indian chiefs and Girty and his fellows, found a ready response to their cry for
resistance and revenge. So well were their measures taken that they killed and
captured the greater part of Crawford's command. Williamson, the murderer of the
Moravians, escaped, deserting homeward before the crisis of the expedition. The
torture of Crawford and his death at the stake, the fiendish laughter of Girty,
as he witnessed his agony and denied the wretched sufferer's prayer for speedy
death, have come down to us in the narrative of an eye witness. The dreadful
story need not be here repeated. The fortitude of the dying soldier was as
conspicuous as were his agonies prolonged and acute. He died bravely and the
story of his death is one of the most familiar examples of Indian barbarity.
Let us, however, now that a century has elapsed since that dark deed was done,
recognize how great was the provocation that inspired Captain Pipe and his
Indians. It was retaliation by extermination and torture on the part of the rude
savage who knew no other code, against Crawford's open boast that he came to
destroy friend and foe alike.
We may well fell a pride in the fact that, although the brunt of Indian
vengeance was born by Kentucky, though her best blood paid the penalty of
Williamson's crime and Crawford's error, no Kentuckian had lot or part in
either. Neither expedition was suggested, organized, or promoted in any respect
by the Kentucky settlers.
In all the chronicles of those long years from Finley's first journey in 1767 to
the end of the Indian wars at the Battle of the Thames in 1813, no instance,
save McGary's murder of Moluntha, occurs where Kentuckians met the foe on other
than equal terms and in fair fight. Hundreds of instances attest their equal
readiness for single combat or contest of numbers, and almost every encounter
brought death to the pioneer or his foe, but the escutcheon of Kentucky has
never been tarnished with the blot of cruelty, nor her lofty courage soiled, by
massacre of the defenseless, or by indignity to prisoners of war.
The excitement of Crawford's expedition and the exultation that followed his
defeat, enabled Girty and the chiefs to arrange with celerity and secrecy for a
formidable incursion into Kentucky. The warriors ere flushed with victory and
mad with hate. An army of whites had already been destroyed and the prestige of
the Indian name restored by a victory in the open field over a well equipped
force, commanded by a veteran and trusted officer. An achievement had crowned
the Indian arms greater than the victory over Braddock or the successes of
Pontiac and his allies. Heretofore ambuscade and surprise had been their
reliance. Crawford's defeat and capture had shown that the Indian could defend
his own country with equal numbers in the open field. The dream of Pontiac
seemed realized, the confederation, which he had labored to organize, seemed now
accomplished, and its mission at hand. The warriors of all that broad territory
that stretched from the Ohio to the lakes and extended from the Wabash on the
west to Fort Pitt and the Allegheny River on the east, were united in counsel
and in hope. The concerted action of all the ablest chiefs gave direction to a
universal impatience for a march in attack. The great league, which Pontiac had
once before formed, and which in after years, was to be revived by Tecumseh, in
the death struggle of the Indian power, was consolidated and ready for immediate
e action. No opportunity ever presented itself to the Indian at one so full of
hope and so stimulating to his patriotism.
The chiefs, in passionate language called for a march that was to recover their
old hunting grounds, and at the same time, secure themselves from invasion. If
the continued settlement of Kentucky were to be allowed without resistance, the
fate of the Northwest was only too plain; but could the victorious league sweep
from the soil of Kentucky the scattered occupants that in seven years' time had
dotted its isolated center and exterminate the pioneers as Crawford had been
defeated, then would the West be indeed regained and the Alleghenies become once
more the bound to the white man's intrusion, and the bulwark of the Indian
territory.
It was a large and bold design that inspired the able chiefs of the confederated
tribes. Their purpose was to regain Kentucky...the entire West from the Gulf
northward to the lakes, and that purpose must have succeeded but for the men
whose bones lie buried here...
It was Monday, the 19th of August, just one hundred years ago. AS the morning
advanced, the speed of the pursuit was quickened, for many unerring signs
betokened that the enemy could not be very far in advance. Still all was order
and circumspection, for the leaders were as prudent as they were brave and every
man was a veteran. The advance continued still following the trace and well
marked route of the foe. Yet not an Indian was seen nor any preparation for
resistance observed. Farther still, the Kentuckians pressed on, vigilant against
surprise and wary of ambuscade and still the enemy were unreached.
But as the column approached the Licking River, the advanced guard caught the
first sight of Indians on the further bank. Girty had safely crossed the stream
and felt that he had the vantage ground, as well as superiority of numbers.
The Indians, when first seen, were leisurely ascending the rocky ridge that
leads up from the river on its southern bank. They were but few. They paused and
seemed to regard the whites with indifference, and then disappeared over the
crest of yonder hill.
Time has not yet effaced the features that then marked this spot. For ages, the
grateful salt sulphur spring that gives it name, had been, the resort of
countless buffaloes, whose sharp hoofs had worn away the soil and destroyed
vegetation. The noble forest that crowned the surrounding scenery was there
obliterated. The trace, which the pursuers had followed, coming down to the
stream by a narrow and difficult approach on the south bank, led up the bare
acclivity on the other side, surmounting its crest where a narrow ridge gave
passageway between two ravines that spread on either side, with easy sweep
towards the stream. Here it was that the Indians chose their battlefield.
A better choice could not have been made, whether the purpose were to resist an
assault or lay an ambuscade. The warriors wee carefully secreted within the
dense shrubbery that filled the ravines, and there awaited the approach of the
whites.
The pioneers stopped on the southern bank for consultation. It must be plain to
all who will recall the circumstances of the assembly and the march and bear in
mind that the whole country was arouse and in motion to reinforce them, that the
pioneers had but little cause to fear an attack. Their position was strong.
Flanked by yonder difficult hills and protected by the river in their front,
they might well have county on repelling assault and holding good their own
until the coming up of their friends, would enable them to take the aggressive.
There was no cause or reason for retreat, but the question of advance was one of
profound moment.
Whose voice should have weight in such a crisis? Whose counsel should control or
whose opinion govern? All eyes turned to the veteran, who better than living man
knew the foe before them, and all listened with respectful attention to the
simple reply he gave when interrogated by Todd. His plan was simple. It was to
await the arrival of Logan, already on the march with more than two hundred men.
With such a reinforcement, the Indians could be attacked and victory fairly
expected. And when Logan should arrive, the old veteran further counseled, that
the attack be not made directly up the rocky point, but by flanking the hills
and ravines, so obviously dangerous.
Boone knew the locality perfectly well, for he had repeatedly visited it and
four years before had been captured on the spot and led away a prisoner. He was
entitled, by every right, to advise, and his advice met the approval of all the
wiser and cooler men present...Todd and Trigg and Harlan certainly wished to
await Logan's arrival...Major Silas Harlan had come in 1774, from Berkeley
County Virginia and joined Harrod in his new settlement...Lt. Colonel Stephen
Trigg was a much more recent immigrant to Kentucky, for he only came hither in
1779...It was at the battle of Point Pleasant and in the campaign of 1774
against the Scioto towns, that Todd had his first taste of war, and first proved
his fitness for adventurous life...
The four officers chief in rank agreed that Logan's arrival should be waited
for. The junior officers, Majors Levi Todd and McBride, Captains Patterson,
Gordon, Bulger and others acquiesced. The entire command was content to obey the
order to halt from those whose courage and judgment they implicitly trusted.
But there was one man whose restless and insubordinate nature and rash
indifference to danger could not brook the delay. To his charge has justly been
laid the disorder, the tumultuous and blind rush, the heedless and unhappy
disregard of Boone's counsel and Todd's commands, the brave lives lost on that
day.
The name of Major Hugh McGary will be remembered until Kentuckians forget the
story of the pioneers. It will be mentioned whenever men tell of the battle of
the Blue Licks. It will remain conspicuous in the annals of our earlier times.
But it is a sad and unenviable fame that has survived him. Even his virtues of
courage and endurance come down to us and will be further transmitted in our
history clouded by the great misfortune of which he was the cause. He was a
rude, brave, violent man. No early discipline, either of the family or the
school, had taught him deference to the authority of others, or formed the habit
of self-control. The resolute and tranquil philosophy of Boone he could not
understand. The large and noble character of Logan was beyond his comprehension,
and he despised the accomplishments of Todd and Trigg. His daring was
proverbial, and his adventures as rash as they were numerous. But his bravest
feats were of times the outgrowth of mere turbulence, and soiled by the
inspiration of personal revenge. He rose not to the noble thought that a new
people and a great State were to honor in the coming years, those who with
unselfish courage should lay the foundations of the Commonwealth. Revenge for
the loss of his horses was his highest motive for Indian war. Envy, too perhaps,
unknown to himself, gave to his judgments of men and their motives, an often
sinister cast. Happily, there is no other instance of that malign passion in the
history or traditions of our pioneers.
He was foremost in every peril and prominent in every strife. His hot blood made
him dangerous even to his friends, and he once was scarce prevented by his own
wife form shooting down James Harrod in some trifling dispute.
It was he who, as late as 1788, murdered the old Shawnee, Chief Moluntha, simply
because he had participated in the Battle of the Blue Licks, and with ruffian
vociferation, denounced all who condemned the foul deed.
But the courage and reckless daring with which he courted peril made him a man
of mark and value in those dangerous times. Offended perhaps at not being called
into the consultation that had just been held, McGary chose to construe as a
want of proper courage, the obvious prudence of his superior officers. A few hot
words passed as he spoke with Todd and Boone and then with headlong impetuosity,
he turned his horse's head and dashed into the stream, calling on all who were
not cowards, to follow him.
The unfortunate example was contagious, whether it was that they imagined that
the order for advance had been given or whether because of mere unreasoning
enthusiasm, the hunter-soldiers followed with a shout and rushed in disorder
across the ford. It was in vain, that Todd and Boone and Trigg and Harlan
endeavored to restrain the excited crowd. Their men were deaf to entreaty and to
command. The entire force passed the river, and they had no choice but to
follow. With utmost difficulty a that was induce, after the crossing was
accomplished on yon low ground, where the ridge comes down with its rocky base
to join the narrow plain. Disorder reigned and authority had been defied. The
scene lies there before us. Survey it and judge ye whose eyes have witnessed
hard fought fields and who have been taught in the greatest of wars. Consider
their difficulties and dangers, the peril of their new position and vindicate
the memory of Boone and Todd.
The barrier of the river in front had been abandoned. Those flanking hills and
the narrow ford, that forbade attack so long as the river intervened, could no
longer afford protection to the little band. The river and its difficult passage
was now in their rear. No kindly shelter covered either flank. In front was the
rocky acclivity rising with rugged ascent to the point where the buffalo trace
disappeared over the hilltop, its nakedness relieved only by the thick branches
and stunted cedars that made it the more difficult to surmount.
To recross the river was impossible. McGary's insubordination had so infected
the men that it was not to be though of. To remain in the new position was
madness, even had the contest been one of equal numbers. No choice was left but
to advance to where fortune should offer a new and safer halting place. With
customary prudence, Boone advised a careful examination towards the front. The
bold men sent forward to reconnoiter passed the ridge, inspecting as they went
either side of the road. They examined with care those converging ravines and
the narrow way between them at the crest. Still further they went, until they
had explore a hl mile or more beyond. They were faithful men and brave, they
were chosen because of their experience. How came it that they made report that
no enemy was to be found?
Girty handled his Indians with ability and firmness. His clear judgment
appreciated the prospect for a victory that the locality afforded him. He had
enough of authority to cause his Indians to fall back noiselessly and rapidly on
either side, back from the sides of the trace and from the ravines into the
dense and secure cover of the adjoining hills. There they lay in perfect silence
and secrecy while the reconnaissance was made. As the scouts passed in return
towards the river, the Indians, with perfect order and in dead silence, moved
back to their chosen position.
It was a masterly move, most difficult of performance and most completely
performed. It stamps Girty as a soldier and his powers of command as
extraordinary.
The report of the reconnoitering party was explicit and satisfactory. All had
right to accept it; none discredited it. Even Boone's caution seems to have been
satisfied and his apprehension allayed. The advance commenced.
Ranged in single line its center pursuing the trace, while o either hand the
flanks extended beyond it, the little army was told off into three divisions.
Boone was on the left, there towards the west; Trigg was on the right and with
him the Harrodsburg troops. Todd remained in the center in general command,
while Major McGary had charge of that body. In front of all Harlan with
twenty-five men, moved up the trace as an advanced guard. The difficult march up
the hill continued until Harlan had reached the crest, where the ravings
converge. The mainbody was just surmounting the slope. The Kentuckians were well
within the net, and the murderous fire began.
The Indians, from their secure cover and at short range, began their battle on
the right. Trigg and nearly all the men from Harrodsburg fell in a brief space.
Instant, Harlan was fired upon from both flanks and he and all his men but three
were killed. The sudden and effective fire of the enemy checked the advance and
threw the line into confusion. Girty instantly extended his line and turned the
flank where Trigg had fallen and the Indians in overpowering numbers, rushed
forward with tomahawk and rifle.
The resistance was desperate but hopeless. Todd rallied his men with voice and
example. His white horse made him a conspicuous mark and it was not many minutes
before he received a death shot through the body. Mounting again, careless of
his mortal wound, he renewed his effort to hold the men around the spot where
Boone was still contending on the left. But he day was lost. He was seen to reel
in his saddle, the blood gushing from his wounds, and he fell.
The defeat became a rout. As may well be seen, the place afforded no shelter for
a defeated force. The only hope of safety was in recrossing the river and
regaining the ground which had been so rashly abandoned. The narrow ford was
crowded with fugitives who fell in numbers as they attempted to escape. Last to
leave the field was Boon and his young son, mortally wounded and borne in his
father's army until death ended his agonies.
The wisdom of Todd and Boone had been dreadfully vindicated. McGary survived
unhurt to witness, though he professed not to regret, the fearful consequences
of his insubordinate folly. The renegade Girty had glutted his vengeance in the
best blood of Kentucky, and pursued his way across the Ohio, no more to appear
upon its soil. Thirty years were to pass before he should again confront
Kentuckians in fight, and yield his life, where Tecumseh fell, to the rifles of
the sons of the pioneers.
The day close. Its sun went down on an anguish that was unspeakable. Desolation
and mourning had come to every station within the settlements, and sorrow was in
every heart. For the fallen were good men of the people. They were the heads of
families, the husbands of wives now unprotected, the fathers of little ones, now
orphans in a wilderness. They were the hope of the rising state, its strong
defense in its need; its tried and true and brave citizens.
In every settlement, in every cabin the dry of woe was heard. Those who had not
lost husbands, wept for slain brothers, or cowered in agony at the though that
strong fathers would never more return. No one but lamented a friend. The whole
of the people was stricken sore. The common danger and the habit of mutual aid
in their perils and privations, had made, as it wee, one family of all the
pioneers.
Strong men wept as they comforted the widows of their friends, and vowed
fatherly care for their little ones.
And while the universal grief went up for the slain and the bereaved, the hearts
of men wee warmed with a noble glow as the unselfish bravery of that fatal day
was told. Those who survived brought the word how gallantly Todd and Trigg and
Harlan and McBride, Bulger and Gordon, Overton and McConnell, Lindsay and
Graham, and Kennedy and Stewart and others, had died in the bloody fight. The
country rang with praise of those who, like Netherland, were conspicuously
heroic and like Reynolds, saved the lives of friends at the peril of their own.
The dreadful sacrifice was not in vain, for the fight of that day was the
decisive struggle for supremacy in Kentucky. The men who died on this spot
achieved in their death the future safety of their friends and the State. The
last incursion of an Indian force had been attempted and no more, were able, and
cruel men to assemble tribes and march savage armies into our border. The great
danger was forever gone. The recovery of Kentucky was never again attempted. The
homes of the pioneers were for all time secure. It was for this that the devoted
band died, and this in their death they achieved. The result was worth the
sacrifice, great as the sacrifice was. In the blood of that day was cemented the
solid foundations of a powerful State. A victory was plucked from defeat.
The news of the disaster quickly reached Logan, who was pushing on with a strong
reinforcement. Too late the survivors saw how Logan's aid would have saved the
day. One melancholy duty only was to be performed. The mutilated bodies of the
slain were reverently collected and interred on the field of battle. And here
they have laid for an hundred years, sepulchered in the soil they loved so well.
Their sleep has been the rest of warriors in honored graves.