George POWERS, Appellant, v. KNOX COUNTY, Kentucky et al., Appellees.
427 S.W.2d 807
Court of Appeals of Kentucky.
May 10, 1968.
ACTION: Appeal dismissed.

Suit involving destruction of private passway. The Circuit Court, Knox County, B. Robert Stivers, J., entered judgment and plaintiff appealed. The Court of Appeals, Davis, C., held that where in one of suits for destruction of private passway, plaintiff prayed for damages for $2,500, but agreed judgment was entered directing county to provide roadway and allow the recovery of $200 and costs, and later supplemental judgment recited that county had made a good faith offer to pay $250 and court approved that offer, record on appeal to court of appeals did not disclose that amount on appeal was as much as $2,500, the jurisdictional amount.

DAVIS, Commissioner.
George Powers has undertaken this appeal as a matter of right, asserting in his statement of appeal that the jurisdictional amount on appeal is $2500. KRS 21.060. Our examination of the record does not disclose that the amount on appeal is as much as $2500, and the appeal must be dismissed as not being prosecuted upon motion.

Appellant filed suit against Knox County, asserting that the county had destroyed a private passway he owned. In his original action a judgment was entered directing the county to provide him with a satisfactory substitute passway, but no monetary recovery was sought or allowed through that judgment. When the fiscal court failed to comply with the first judgment, appellant filed a second suit looking toward enforcement of the first judgment and praying for damages of $2500. An agreed judgment was entered in the second case directing the county to provide a roadway and allowing recovery of $200 and costs to Powers.

When the county failed to comply with the terms of the second judgment, motions were made by Powers seeking to enforce the judgment. The court set the matter for hearing and viewed the roadway as ultimately provided by the county and with which Powers is dissatisfied. The court entered a supplemental judgment on February 17, 1966, in which it was recited that the approach, as built, substantially complies with the terms of the original judgment; and the case was left upon the court's docket upon the question of damages only. However, on February 22, 1966, the court entered a second supplemental judgment in which it was recited that the county had made a good-faith offer to pay Powers $250 (whether in satisfaction of the original $200 in the agreed judgment is not disclosed) which offer of $250 had never been withdrawn and was approved by the circuit court in the second supplemental judgment of February 22.

It is from this morass of judgments that the present appeal has been undertaken, but we can find nothing in the record to justify any claim that the amount in controversy on appeal is as much as $2500. In such circumstances, the appeal must be dismissed.

The appeal is dismissed.

All concur.
Powers v. Knox County
427 S.W.2d 807


Last Update Tuesday, 18-Dec-2012 01:32:10 EST

 County Coordinator
County Coordinator: Gayle Triller
Copyright © 2015 by the KYGenWeb Team. All
rights reserved. Copyright of submitted items
belongs to those responsible for their authorship or
creation unless otherwise assigned.