|Botkins v. Com.|
|394 S.W.2d 586|
|Oct. 1, 1965.|
Prosecution for embezzlement. From conviction in the Circuit Court of Knox County, B. Robert Stivers, J., defendant appealed. The Court of Appeals, Montgomery, J., held that evidence was sufficient to sustain verdict, that indictment which set forth plain, concise, and definite statement of essential facts constituting specific offense was not invalid for failure to cite proper criminal statute or for failure to allege facts required for conviction under statute actually cited, and that an objection to an instruction could not be raised for first time on appeal.
Elbert Botkins was convicted of embezzling $11.65 paid to him as Justice of the Peace on a fine. He was sentenced to one year's confinement. He appeals and argues that he was indicted under KRS 434.010 which does not cover the offense of which he was convicted; the indictment is invalid and the instruction is erroneous for failure to charge intent as provided in KRS 434.020; and the verdict is flagrantly against the evidence.
In substance the testimony for the Commonwealth shows that Tom Black paid appellant $11.65 on a fine for his son, Charles Foley Black; that appellant received the money in his capacity as Justice of the Peace of the Third Magisterial District of Knox County; that appellant executed a receipt dated October 2, 1962, for the payment of the fine; and that the Knox County records with respect to the collection of fines and forfeitures did not show that appellant had ever turned in or reported a fine against Charles Foley Black in any amount. From this testimony the jury could have believed that appellant, in his official capacity, collected and failed to account for $11.65 of the Charles Foley Black fine. It is sufficient to sustain the verdict.
Appellant said that to the best of his knowledge he had never collected a fine from Charles Foley Black and that he did not know what the receipt to Tom Black was for or what it represented. The indictment, in part, charged as follows:
'EMBEZZELMENT (sic) A Justice of the Peace of the Third Magisterial District, Knox County, Kentucky, embezzled Eleven dollars sixty five cents ($11.65) cents (sic) of said County's money, same being paid by Tom Black on a fine for Charles Foley Black.'
Generally embezzlement may be defined as the fraudulent appropriation or conversion by an agent, an employee, a corporate officer, a trustee, or other person acting in a fiduciary capacity, or character, of money or property, the possession of which has been entrusted to him by another. The use of the words 'embezzlement' and 'embezzled,' as well as other descriptive words, plainly charges an offense under KRS 434.020.
Lastly, it is argued that the instruction was faulty for failure to say that the act must be done with intent to deprive the owner of his property. The instruction required the jury to believe that the defendant 'misapplied' a certain sum.
The Watkins case is distinguishable. Here, the instruction required the jury to believe beyond a reasonable doubt that the appellant did 'unlawfully, fraudulently and feloniously, convert to his own use' the money entrusted to him. While it would have been better practice to include the statutory language referring to intent, it is considered that the use of the phrase 'convert to his own use' connotes a purposeful or intentional diversion of the money from its proper use to his own use, which is sufficient for the jury's understanding of the offense and its nature. There is no such connotation in the use of the word 'mis-applied'.. The instruction given was not prejudicial. However, appellant cannot now question the correctness of the instruction since the record does not reveal any objection to it at any stage of the proceeding. Hence, it is too late to raise it for the first time on appeal.
BOTKINS v. COMMONWEALTH
394 S.W.2d 586
Last Update Tuesday, 18-Dec-2012 01:31:08 EST
Copyright © 2015 by the KYGenWeb Team. All
rights reserved. Copyright of submitted items
belongs to those responsible for their authorship or
creation unless otherwise assigned.